By Editor Edison – CalPatty Press Editor for Revenge of the Ghost Wolf

cottrllappealcover

Thanks to Karen Elkin the Gilmer County Circuit Court Clerk for sending me these documents in a timely manner so that I could share the long awaited APPEAL to the GILMER COUNTY FINAL RESOLUTION shown above and this 16 page document is absolute dribble from beginning to end and truly really does not contain a valid argument.  February the 5th the Gilmer County Commission after five years of effort and several fiduciary commissioners for the Cottrill Estate presented their final proposed settlement, the final resolution of the Cottrill Estate.  The final resolution was ordered by Judge Alsop, so the Gilmer County Commission was given only 120 days to come up with their final decision on the matter. That document was published earlier in RGW and all the heirs named above on the cover page of the appeal have to give back all benefits and monies received and forfeit any ownership to the land having to do with the estate. The sale to Richard Neal, will be as it never happened, and the DEED will be VOID as soon as that document is signed by the judge.

cottrillappealpage2

PAGE 2 found above of the APPEAL by the EXECUTOR and THREE HEIRS to the WILLARD COTTRILL ESTATE shows that the plaintiffs disagree with the findings of the commission, but they DO NOT ARGUE WHY they disagree, and they do not make a point of why the resolution should not take effect upon the judges signature.  If you look above you see they state they disagree with the findings of the GC Commission, but AGAIN this page contains NO REAL ARGUMENT and the bullet points should have been numbered so that they could be referenced in the courtroom. Review the document above, this idiot states facts of disagreement but MAKES NO ARGUMENT which is what an appeal is, it is suppose to be an argument based on grounds, but obviously they could find no grounds to argue their appeal as shown above.

THE MOST RIDICULOUS PART OF PAGE TWO IS THE MENTION OF MARLEA COTTRILL CONTESTING THE WILL BUT YET THEY DID NOT SAY HOW THAT WAS DONE OR ANY FACTS PROVING THAT SHE CONTESTED THE WILL WHICH, SHE DID NOT — THESE TYPES OF CLAIMS ABOVE ON PAGE TWO MAKE THIS ENTIRE DOCUMENT A JOKE AND A MOCKERY OF THE GILMER COUNTY COURT SYSTEM FOR THIS MIKE MURPHY MANIAC HAS BEEN ALLOWED TO CAUSE HARM FOR MUCH TOO LONG.

cottrillappealpage3

By the time we finally start to review page three it becomes very obvious to this reporter that what we have here is a FRIVOLOUS APPEAL

A frivolous appeal is determined by two different standards: subjective and objective.  The subjective standard looks at the motives – such as bad faith or for delay – of the appellant and/or attorney.  The objective standard addresses the merits of an appeal from a reasonable person’s perspective, i.e., whether the reasonable person would agree the appeal was totally devoid of merit. (In re Marriage of Flaherty (1982) 31 Cal.3d 637,649.)

This page above actually contains the word ARGUMENT, but where the hell is the argument? I see no real argument presented on page 3 so it is obvious Murphy has no realization of what an APPEAL is.

cottrillappealpage4

Page 4 above does give us some history in chronological order which is good for the files and actually does contain some information this reporter did not have previously regarding possible buyers of the Willard Cottrill Estate. But if you review it, again WHERE is an argument? It is just stating facts about Ruth Mitchell that were already decided in WV Supreme Court so why bring it up since that matter was ruled on?

Page 4 also contains some history on the involvement of Timothy Butcher who gives his opinion on where Ruth Mitchell should live which the Supreme Court disagreed with, so Butchers two cents on the matter was not worth a pile of Billy Goat Poop up at the house of the Goatman Richard Neal who is busy planting a garden on the Cottrill Estate thinking this APPEAL will win his stay, but he will have to move soon. The GOATMAN has also been a coverin up  big tractor tracks leading up to a secluded hunting cabin where they have been doing GOD-KNOWS-WHAT thinking they own the place, when soon, after this appeal is denied the GOATMAN will find his deed VOID.

cottrillappealpage5

Page FIVE above is more or less a history lesson that is not entirely accurate, but contains NO ARGUMENT and NO MERIT FOR APPEAL  This page does show that the executor and the heirs he claims to represent completely forgetting there is a fourth heir, has gone to the trouble of hiring an attorney for $4,000.00 at the estates expense to argue a matter that goes directly against the will of Willard Cottrill which is 180 degrees from the duties of any executor proving MIKE MURPHY is a SHAM and really not very bright for the fact, that the matter is completely in the open now and being published.

cottrillappealpage6

Page SIX is about all I can stand to share with the general public before publishing the CONCLUSION without throwing up. In fact, I just had my assistant bring me a COKE to settle my stomach for this document will make you want to puke if you read thru the entire 16 pages.  The reason I wanted to publish this page is that it illustrates that the judge thought that just by filing an action to remove Ruth Mitchell the long time companion of Willard Cottrill was, in fact, in and of itself contesting the will.

The answer by attorney Criswell is DUMBER than DUMB so I would like to know where she attended law school. She states, “ The beneficiaries and I would argue that she is not a beneficiary and is not entitled to any right or title to the property that was owned by Willard Cottrill at the time of his death…”

Never was it mentioned in the will that Ruth was beneficiary to property, it only stated that Willard wanted Ruth to have a Roof over her head and live in the home she lived in like she had while he was still alive.

That is what the will said, so Criswell obviously misinterpreted the entire matter which showed a lack of preparation for the case.

Cottrillconclusionpage1

PAGE 15 the beginning of the Conclusion  illustrates to me what a complete and total idiot Mike Murpy the executor of the Cottril Estate really is, for misusing words like ACCEPTED when explaining the matter of his submitting his FINAL ACCOUNTING.

Notice how Murphy says the Commission declined to close the estate, well JESUS there was a good reason for that. It was for the reason Linda Huff the fiduciary commissioner found more wrong with Murphys final accounting than you can shake a stick at!

AGAIN MURPHY GIVES US A HISTORY LESSON BECAUSE HE DOES NOT KNOW THAT HE IS SUPPOSE TO BACK UP HIS ARGUMENTS INTO ONE COHESIVE FORCE WITH THE CONCLUSION BUT THERE WERE NO REAL ARGUMENTS SO THIS CONCLUSION IS A REAL JOKE!!

cottrillconclusionpage2

PAGE 16 and the final page of the document, asks the circuit court to order the actions noted above! Murphy asks the judge to dismiss the proposed settlement and final resolution of the Willard Cottrill Estate after FIVE LONG YEARS of getting the matter resolved to their liking.  I truly doubt the judge will take any requests seriously. 

THE SECOND REQUEST IS SO RIDICULOUS AS TO BE LAUGHED OUT LOUD AT FOR MURPHY ASKS A CIRCUIT COURT JUDGE TO CHANGE HIS RULING THAT WAS UPHELD AND AFFIRMED BY A VOTE OF 4 to 1 by the West Virginia Supreme Court which really puts the icing on this pathetic cake.

I HAVE BAD NEWS FOR MIKE MURPHY FOR HIS APPEAL IS NOT GOING TO FLY AND THE JUDGE WILL NOT RELEASE THE BOND — THE BOND WILL HAVE TO COVER THE LOSSES OF THE ESTATE WHICH COULD TALLY UPWARDS TO OVER $300,000.00 cash after all facts are considered.

It is my opinion that on April 11th when this matter goes before judge ALSOP, the judge will sign the final resolution and deny the appeal of Mike Murphy.

**

Can’t ya hear us knockin Goatman it will be real soon with the eviction notice!!

Yeah, you got satin shoes Goatman
Yeah, you got plastic boots Goatman
Y’all got cocaine eyes
Yeah, you got speed-freak jive
Can’t you hear me knockin’ on your window
Can’t you hear me knockin’ on your door
Can’t you hear me knockin’ down your dirty street, yeah

The Ghost Wolf says hear me prowlin’ Goatman
I’m gonna take you down
Hear me growlin’  Goatman
Yeah, I’ve got flatted feet now, now, now, now
Hear me howlin’ A  ooooh!
And all, all around your street now
Hear me knockin’
And all, all around your town